Wednesday, December 30, 2009

Penny Arbitrage, the US Dollar, and the Commodities Market

Question: When is a penny worth more than a penny?

Answer: When there’s the chance for penny arbitrage.

Arbitrage is any investor’s dream come true! It is an opportunity to make money through a trade with zero risk of a loss. Literally: in an arbitrage situation, you cannot lose. If you can, then its not true arbitrage. While this may sound too good to be true, arbitrage is quite possible, and there is an entire niche of specialized investors who are constantly hunting down the latest chance to taken advantage of it. Arbitrage is an idiosyncrasy of the free market: as much as it might burn some people who don’t take advantage of it—including “people” of the international finance realm like those are the BIS, IMF, etc—arbitrage reveals locality in pricing over global uniformity. Therefore, of course, globalists hate arbitrage, because that locality threatens the centralized world they seek to unilaterally control. Here’s the IMF’s explanation of arbitrage, from
Demystifing Hedge Funds, an external document on the IMF's website:

"The technique of arbitrage tries to profit from the fact that sometimes an asset trades at a different price in different markets at the same time. Because an asset should have the same price in all markets at the same time, a way to capture a low-risk profit is to sell the higher-priced asset in one market (sell it short) and buy the lower-priced asset (buy it long) in the other market. When the prices converge, an arbitrage profit can be captured by selling the formerly low-priced asset and buying back the formerly high-priced asset. A typical example of potential arbitrage opportunities is company bonds that are convertible into equity shares of the company.”

Please note, by “asset,” the authors are talking about financial assets—market-traded securities, stocks, debt, derivatives, etc—and not off-exchange commodities. Commodities often have different prices in different geographic areas: bananas are cheaper in Guatemala than in Russia, right? The availability of a commodity is often geographically limited or specific, thus the above-mentioned “assets” are those electronically exchanged paper assets which are equally accessible in all corners of the planet. Indeed, commodities can be lsited on exchanges, and when they are, they also be subject to price uniformity, and possibily arbitrage when locality breaks that uniformity. Just recently, a
major arbitrage oppurtunity occured for Chinese copper traders who spotted a price difference between the London Metals Exchange (LME) price and the Shanghai price on futures contracts for copper: within hours, these savvy traders rallied the price up and pocketed a risk-free return. And of course, they never even touched the metal. It is pure arbitrage.

Arbitrage is not Chiquita buying bananas in Guatemala for $0.02/lbs, bringing them to the US, and selling them for $0.69/lbs. Chiquita is not conducting arbitrage because, while if everything goes well, they’ll make a nice profit, it is also possible that they could lose money. True arbitrage is totally protected from loss. Chiquita is trading: they are moving the cheap-to-produce, widely available, local commodity of bananas from a place like Guatemala to a higher-priced market where the bananas are otherwise unavailable, like Minnesota. Chiquita takes a risk and could lose: after all, the banana ship could get raided by gorilla pirates (not guerillas, but actual gorillas!), who eat all the bananas, kill the crew, and sink the ship. Its not likely, but its possible, and now Chiquita is out a load of bananas, a crew, and a ship. Therefore, there is risk to Chiquita’s venture, and so it is not arbitrage. Remember: arbitrage carries zero risk­—it must be impossible to lose. Also, true arbitrage happens nearly instantly: the trade is executed and the profit is collected. So, then, what is an example of arbitrage, and how to pennies relate to this?

Think about pennies while this example of arbitrage unfolds. Probably the simplest, easiest, and most common form of arbitrage happens when a trader realizes that the convertible bonds (bonds of a company that can be converted to stock in that same company) have a premium (or discount) to the current price of the equity (stock). This is called convertible arbitrage.
Demystifing Hedge Funds explains it as:

Convertible arbitrage. A strategy in which managers purchase a portfolio of securities that are convertible into other kinds of securities. For example, corporate bonds are often convertible into equity shares of the issuing companies. Normally, the prices of the bonds and shares trade in a close relationship. Sometimes bond and stock market conditions cause the prices to get out of line. Hedge funds buy and sell the bonds and stocks simultaneously, pushing the prices back into line and profiting from market mispricing."

Let’s say you are a trader. You are looking through convertible bonds, and notice that Company Z’s stock is trading at $10 a share. You also notice, however, that for some reason, Company Z’s convertible bonds are trading at 99% of face value, and are convertible to 11 shares. You do the math: you can buy $100 face value of Company Z’s bonds for $99, and it convert to 11 shares at $10 a share. In other words, you can buy spend $99 and get $110, instantly. You don’t know anything about Company Z, nor do you particularly care, because you will execute the buy and sell of the bonds and converted stocks instantly and simultaneously. Others, of course, will quickly notice this, and soon those with the bonds which you seek to purchase will demand a higher price (or convert the bonds to stocks themselves), and/or those with the stock you wish to buy will sell and buys bonds, thus driving down the price of the stock. Either way, the arbitrage will quickly evaporate, as the bond price will go lower or the stock price will go higher to equalize, or the stock will go higher and the bonds lower. Either way, those others in the market with Company Z bonds/stocks will have the market power to demand a higher price which will correct the arbitrage situations.

So, in convertible arbitrage the trader exercises the right to convert one to the other, or use one to purchase the other at a zero risk of loss. It must be instantaneously, electronically accomplished so that the arbitrager never “holds” the bonds/stocks, which will soon be subject to correction. The other huge example (though much less common) version is regulatory arbitrage. In regulatory arbitrage, traders can take advantage of some legal constraint that varies in different markets. Regulatory arbitrage plays one government’s policies against another, or with Basel II, one securitization framework against the other. There are financial geniuses in the
regulatory arbitrage market, who have, as mere individuals, actually greatly hampered the Bank for International Settlements’ push for “standardisation” by revealing that the BIS’ Basel II framework itself is wrought with contradictions and arbitrage opportunities—and they are using it against the banks with great success. And banks themselves use regulatory arbitrage. Regulatory arbitrage along these lines, according to many analysts and the disgruntled finance ministers of the top twenty economies (aka the G20), had a significant role in sparking the current meltdown, particularly and specifically with the Basel II minimum capital requirement’s various ridiculous “capital calculation” schemes. (But I’m getting sidetracked: there will be a complete post on the role of regulatory arbitrage in Basel II soon.) So, that’s basic financial asset arbitrage. It’s a simple concept, even though the execution can be a little complex, and arbitrage helps keep prices of financial assets in line throughout the global paper investment market.

Thus is one example of paper asset arbitrage. Now for commodities arbitrage—penny arbitrage. I acknowledge outright that my penny arbitrage example is in no way a true arbitrage, because you cannot instantly make profits nor can you execute it while sitting behind a trader screen. To be totally technical, penny “arbitrage” is more like a hedge, as one “asset” (the penny) exposes the holder to two different markets simultaneously—the copper market (as a copper penny) and the currency market (as a unit of the US dollar). But unlike hedging, it actually carries zero risk--you'll always have whatever you started with. Therefore, I’m going to call it penny arbitrage, and maybe you’ll see why and agree.

Penny arbitrage demonstrates what fiat money does: it disintegrates value. Reach into your pocket, and pull out all of the change. Of course, we already know that any pre-1965 quarters or dimes that you might have in that mix are 90% silver, and therefore, currently, those silver coins are worth more than ten times the face value (in fact, with silver at about $17/oz today, they’re worth over twelve times face value). But, in all honesty, it is not very likely that you’ll have a pre-1965 quarter or dime. Most of the silver coins have been pulled from circulation by investors and collectors who know what they are worth, and so you’ll have to pay the about $12.29 for 4 silver quarters (in other words, $12.29 for $1 face value). That said, however, it is very likely that you’ll have some pennies. And it is also very likely that you’ll have some copper pennies.

So, do it now, check your pennies: any one with a date of 1981 or older is a 95% copper coin. During 1982, the penny’s composition was changed from 95% copper, 5% zinc to 95% zinc, and only 5% copper (coating), due to the increasing price of copper, which had
peaked to over $1/lb in 1980, and was holding steady above $0.70/lb. (Do you see where this is going yet?) Some 1982 pennies are 95% copper, and some are 95% zinc, but you cannot easily tell unless you weigh them: the copper pennies weigh about 3.1 gm, and the zinc pennies weigh about 2.5 gm. Of course, the price of copper wasn’t simply increasing on its own in a vacuum as industrial commodity: the price of copper was increasing relative to the value of the dollar (or, in this case, the penny), which, because of its inflationary fiat nature, is constantly deteriorating. Congress changed the composition of pennies in 1982 because the cost of making the physical coins was increasing, while the purchasing power value of each $0.01 was decreasing.

Now for the arbitrage: those easy-to-find copper pennies have a declared face value of $0.01. Therefore, for monetary exchange, a penny (whether copper or not) is worth only $0.01. But, as copper, your little penny exposes you to the commodities market, and as metal, the little thing is worth more that double the face value—its actually worth a whopping $0.02 (or 0.0217498, to be more precise, today, Dec 30 2009, with copper at $3.35/lb). That is penny arbitrage.

As stated above, the
mass of a copper penny is 3.1 grams, but as it is 95% copper, the actual copper content is 95% x 3.1 = 2.945 grams. There are 28.35 grams to an ounce (metric converter), and 16 ounces to a pound, therefore 453.6 gm/lb. So, to calculate the price per gram of copper, simply convert the price/lb to price/gm by following this equation:

Price/lb ÷ 453.6 = Price/gm

At $3.35/lb, copper is currently $0.0073853 a gram. At 95% copper, each copper penny contains 2.945 gm copper. Therefore, multiply the price by the content weight, and you’ll see that each copper penny contains $0.0217498 worth of copper, or more than twice the face value.

An easier way to do this is to calculate the number of copper pennies needed to make a pound of copper. Copper pennies are 95% copper and lose very little of their composition through circulation.

Number of 95% copper pennies needed to make 1 lb copper:

453.6 (gm in 1lb of copper) ÷ 2.945 (gm of copper in 1 penny) = 154.023 pennies.

So, you need 155 pennies (or $1.55) to have one pound worth of copper. Of course, as they are 5% zinc, these 155 pennies will actually weigh slightly more than one pound if placed on a scale (they'll weigh 3.1 gm x 155 = 480.5 gm / 453.6 gm (per pound) = 1.059 lbs).

Now, consider that the current price per lb of copper is $3.35 (Dec 30 2009). Do you get it now?

As the table above demonstrates, the price of copper overwhelms the one-cent face value of the penny when the metal hit $1.55/lb. A copper penny will be worth a dime ($0.10) when copper hits $15.41/lb.

For historical comparison, the Treasury could no longer afford to maintain the 90% silver content of halves, quarters, and dimes by 1962. The value of the paper dollar had decreased (read: "had been debased by the Federal Reserve System") to the level that silver was nearing a 1:1 ratio. The year 1964 was the last for 90% silver coins (40% silver halves through 1968, and then all circulating coins were silver-free). Since 1965, when silver traded at roughly $1.10 - 1.29/oz, the price of silver has increased by approximately $16.90, or 1536% (based on recent $18/oz silver; silver is today at about $17, and reached over $20 in early 2008).

Likewise, since gold was removed from the $35/oz peg in 1971, the metal has moved $1065, or 3043% (based on recent approximate $1,100/oz gold).

Therefore, as a monetary unit, a copper penny (and its zinc version) is pegged at $0.01, which sets both the floor value and the investment price for it as an “arbitrage” opportunity. However, as a piece of metal, the old copper penny’s value is over 2 cents. Over the long term, the copper price will likely rise in step with general prices, especially as the industrial demand for copper increases and more nations become industrialized, but an even greater factor in the “price” of copper will be the long-term loss of value of the US dollar unit.

I’ll be the first to declare that copper prices are very volatile: after a 60-year low of $0.60/lb in the 1990’s, copper has spent much of the last
15 years under $1.50/lb, which made the price nearly the same as the $1.55/lb copper-penny price. In 2006, the price of copper and nickel surged, making the coins more valuable as metal than as US currency, and forcing high replacement costs on the US Mint. Until 2006, it was not illegal to melt coins, but facing these high replacement costs, the Treasury prompted the US government to illegalize the melting of pennies and nickels (which are 75% copper, 25% nickel), and impose restrictions on the export of the coins to $100 face value. The copper price moved down in 2007 before again surging during the summer 2008 commodities bubble that pushed oil to $148/barrel. The melt/export ban remains in place for nickels and pennies. (A similar ban was placed on the melting of silver coins as part of the Coinage Act in 1967, and this ban was eventually lifted once the Mint could meet the US coin demand with the “clad” silver-free coins.)

At the 2006 and 2008 $4/lb level, $1.00 in copper pennies was actually worth $2.60 in copper. For the record: I am absolutely NOT suggesting to anyone to melt pennies or nickels—as detailed above, it is a federal crime punishable by a $10,000 fine and five years in prison, or both. I am simply using the difference in the “currency value” of copper pennies versus the “commodities value” of the copper in them to demonstrate what fiat money does to the value of our currency and the spending power of our savings.

So think about what the Federal Reserve’s fiat printing machine is doing to your savings next time you have a little copper penny in your hand. It is not rocket science, and it is not some crazy derivative: a dollar in paper, or as an electronic entry at your bank, is worth $1.00, period. Yet, a dollar in little copper pennies is currently worth $2.17. This is why we call the central bankers by their proper name: central banksters.

Perhaps anyone with electronic “cash” sitting in an account, or paper bills stuffed under a mattress, collecting zero or near zero percent interest should, maybe, think about turning all that savings into pennies, sorting through them, and filling up Arrowhead water jugs with the coppers! Hey--it can be a new home decorating item: a few thousand pounds of copper pennies in whatever will hold them! After all, it really doesn’t take up that much space: according to a very unscientific Google search, a 5-gallon Arrowhead jug filled with copper pennies would weigh about 245 lbs, and contain 35,000 pennies, or about $350 face value in pennies, with a copper content of 95%. Put it in the closet, and when copper is at $10/lb in 15 years, it will be worth $2275, or $1,925 more than the face value. Worst case scenario, the police-state raids your house, takes your pennies, and gives you Federal Reserve notes!

Left as electronic money in a savings account at 5% compounding interest (which you’d be lucky to find these days), that $350 will have grown to just $570 in 10 years (
calculator). Left as cash in an envelope, it will remain at $350, and simply further lose purchasing power as the dollar devalues. Considering this, pennies are looking better by the minute! Plus, there’s the added benefit of denying a banking institution from taking your $350 and leveraging it out at 10:1, "buying" up the economy, further contributing to inflation, strengthening the Federal Reserve System, and continuing the devaluation of the dollar and atrophy of spending power! Why not pennies?

In 1924, in the Weimar Republic, paper money was worth more as
fuel for the fire than currency; in 2009, in Mugabe’s Zimbabwe, a $1,000,000,000,000 (that's one TRILLION) in bank notes was used as wall paper. And today, a little old US penny is worth more as metal than as currency. We’re lucky..,but for how long?


  1. Hi Keri
    Thanks for going public with your blog addy on Rollye's show. I'm super-happy to have a window into your world. I admire Rollye's razor-sharp logic and I think you are just as bright. Keep up the good work! (psyched to be comment No. 1!)

  2. Hi Kaydeross!

    Thanks for checking out the blog, and thanks for being Comment #1! Are you collecting copper pennies yet? :)

  3. Your post are very important for stock market & share market, so keep it up..... all my dear friends if u want to u more profit and lot of earn Money You can drop your number and sign up our site :- <a href="”>Best copper tips provider</a>